Selective morality should not apply
Publish date: 31 July 2007
Issue Number: 21
Diary: Legalbrief Environmental
Category: Development
In a letter to the editor of The Mercury, a reader, Fair Play, comments that the MEC for Environmental Affairs, Mtholephi Mthimkhulu, recently made a courageous statement that the developers requirements should never be an excuse to ignore the voice of the general public, whose rights and interests could be permanently damaged by the developer.
However, the writer notes that environment impact assessment procedures do not only consider environmental issues, but also evaluate the impact on affected people in economic and social terms. As a result, the judgment that the Umhlanga Rocks Pearls development should not be exempt from a public and thorough process of environmental and social scrutiny is applauded. Of course, therefore, it is essential that similar investigations should apply to all government developments i.e. the new airport (in Durban), the new soccer stadium and the Point development. Therefore it remains to be seen whether the MEC has the character and the political power to sustain his concept of ethical assessments for all projects. Full report in The Mercury