Back Print this page
Legalbrief   |   your legal news hub Thursday 19 November 2026

SA cannot keep Dewani safe - lawyer

SA authorities cannot keep honeymoon murder accused Shrien Dewani safe despite earlier assurances, the High Court in London was told yesterday, according to a report in The Times.

Dewani is fighting British Home Secretary Theresa May's order to extradite him to SA to stand trial for the murder of his bride, Anni Hindocha. She was killed in a botched hijacking in Guguletu, Cape Town, in November last year. Dewani's barrister, Clare Montgomery QC, argued that District Judge Howard Riddle had erred in granting the extradition request by SA authorities in August, and that he should not have relied on their promises to protect Dewani's health. Montgomery said the undertakings were limited and did not protect her client from being raped in prison, or violence at the hands of fellow inmates. She said there was 'explicit public hostility' towards Dewani, which had been fanned by statements such as the now infamous 'monkey' reference by suspended National Police Commissioner Bheki Cele. Video footage of the Pappa Wag vir Jou campaign was once again played to the court, with actors portraying inmates supposedly threatening rape to newcomers. Montgomery also said, citing the minutes of a Parliamentary Monitoring Group meeting in August, that, contrary to Riddle's finding and the SA legal team's assertions, there was no free and independent press in SA that would report if Dewani was harmed. Full report in The Times

Not only his health, but his life, too, would be at risk if Dewani were extradited, Montgomery said. According to a report on the IoL site, she argued he was so ill that he would be incapable of giving instructions to his lawyers or following trial proceedings, and extradition should be delayed until he had recovered. The QC told Sir John Thomas, president of the Queen's Bench Division and Justice Ouseley, that the businessman had always wished for a fair trial. 'However that is, at the moment, on the advice we have been given by those who are treating him, not possible.' His illnesses had begun to develop shortly after the murder of his wife and before he was accused of her murder. His recovery is likely to be 'slow and unpredictable'. Full report on the IoL site

Written statements before the court from Dewani's legal team say that his illnesses cannot be treated with anti-depressant medication because he suffers from a life-threatening drug reaction, notes a report on the New24 site. Montgomery told the judges that the risk would increase 'to an unacceptable level' if he were extradited. The suicide management capacity of the SA prison system was 'inadequate', as had been admitted by the prisons inspector, she contended. Experts also agreed that there was no evidence that the psychiatric hospital available to care for him could adequately treat his complex illnesses. Extradition would be incompatible with articles 2 and 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which protect the right to life and prohibit inhuman and degrading treatment. Full report on the News24 site