Hlophe dispute heads to Appeal Court
Freedom Under Law has taken its legal battle to reverse the JSC's decision not to hold a formal inquiry into the 'Hlophe dispute' to the SCA, notes a report in today's Business Day.
After losing in the High Court last year, the NGO, headed by former Constitutional Court justice Johann Kriegler, has now petitioned the Appeal Court for leave to appeal. This was after the High Court refused it leave to appeal last week. The dispute involves allegations that Hlophe had improperly tried to influence the outcome of cases then pending before their court, related to corruption charges against President Jacob Zuma. After more than a year of stops and starts and intervening court cases, the JSC ultimately decided not to hold a formal inquiry, with cross-examination, into the complaints and declared the matter finalised. But its decision provoked dismay in some quarters and Freedom Under Law took the decision to go to court, saying the JSC had shirked its constitutional duty. The report notes the decision also led to another, separate, court case by Western Cape Premier Helen Zille, who successfully argued that she was entitled as Premier to sit on the JSC when it made its decision. An appeal, by the JSC and Hlophe, against the Zille judgment is scheduled to be heard by the SCA next month. While Freedom Under Law had initially distanced itself from Zille's case, it has now asked the Appeal Court to hear both appeals together. Full Business Day report