US threatens SA on G20 outcomes
This weekend’s G20 Summit, hosted by South Africa (SA), is looking increasingly unlikely to issue the usual G20 Leaders’ Declaration, after the US revealed that it would oppose anything beyond a ‘Chair’s Statement’. If so, this 20th summit would be the first since they began in 2008 not to issue a consensus leaders’ declaration. Legalbrief Africa reports that SA President Cyril Ramaphosa has made it clear that the snub will not impact on the mega event: ‘All other heads of state will be here, and in the end, we will take fundamental decisions, and their absence is their loss.’ The prospects of a declaration dimmed considerably after the US spelt out its position at the weekend. ‘The US has sent a clarifying note regarding its participation in the SA Summit. The essence of the message is that Washington will oppose the issuance of any G20 deliverable beyond a Chair’s Statement,’ one of the G20 sherpas said. The Daily Maverick reports that President Donald Trump had earlier announced that no US Government official would attend the summit, which would itself be unprecedented and damaging. In theory, SA and most other G20 members that support its ambitious developmental agenda could simply bypass the US – and its fervent supporter Argentina – and issue a Leaders’ Declaration. However, several G20 countries seem wary of defying the US so openly, and in any case, believe the principle of reaching G20 decisions by consensus should be inviolable. SA’s sherpa, DG of International Relations & Co-operation Zane Dangor, is chairing a meeting this week of all sherpas for G20 member states and guest countries to decide on these and other issues.
One diplomat said the key thing was not the form of the outcome document, but rather to ensure it captured all the important discussions and agreements which had been held over the past year in preparation for the summit. However, John Kirton, director of the G20 Research Group at the University of Toronto, said issuing a Chair’s Statement rather than a Leaders’ Declaration ‘would be a major retreat, especially if the Chair’s Statement had not been seen or discussed and agreed by all members in advance, as it was at the G7 Kananaskis Summit in June. ‘But even a declaration issued without Trump or any US official there would be a major blow. It’s unlikely Trump or US officials would agree to, or feel bound by, one. And the new Argentinian Foreign Minister, having just visited Washington, would probably veto much or all, as Trump would want him to do,’ Kirton said, referring to Argentine President Javier Milei’s announcement that he would send his Foreign Minister Pablo Quirno to represent him. DM notes that Chinese President Xi Jinping, Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum Pardo and Russian President Vladimir Putin are also not attending the summit.
SA's International Relations & Co-operation Minister Ronald Lamola has accused the Trump administration of pursuing an agenda of ‘white supremacy’. ‘It was excruciatingly difficult that there’s fearmongering to pursue the agenda of white supremacy,’ said Lamola about the contentious 21 May meeting at the White House, in which Trump repeated claims of ‘white persecution’. The Sunday Times reports that CNN’s Donie O’Sullivan asked Lamola: ‘Do you think Trump is pursuing the white supremacist agenda? His response: ‘Yes, I think so. With the programme to take white Afrikaners from SA, it’s a clear programme to back up the issue of white supremacy. When you look at the Geneva Convention, they don’t fit the definition of a refugee.’ Meanwhile, with Trump having pulled the plug on all US participation at this year’s G20 Summit, clinging to a discredited and false white genocide narrative, the transfer of the G20 presidency is set for another standoff between the two countries, with Pretoria insisting that the US Government must come to SA to receive a proper handover.
It said it will not travel to the US to hand over the G20 presidency following months of tensions, which have resulted in Trump firing a lethal salvo by announcing that he would not be sending any delegation to the summit and denouncing SA’s participation in the forum. In an interview with the Sunday Times last week, SA’s G20 Sherpa Ambassador Xolisa Mabhongo said ‘there is nothing that SA will do’. ‘They will simply assume their presidency and inform the world what is on their menu … It is what it is, we are in this situation, and that is how we will manage it,’ he said. Traditionally, the country which will assume the presidency takes over the reins following the Leaders’ Summit. During Brazil’s presidency, a high contingent of Ramaphosa’s delegation accompanied him to Rio de Janeiro, where President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva transferred chairship of the group during a ceremonial event. ‘The US can’t wish us away because from 1 December, we then form part of the troika again with the US,’ Ramaphosa’s spokesperson, Vincent Magwenya, told the Sunday Times.
SA finds itself under a sophisticated, multi-pronged assault. In a Sunday Times analysis, Kay Sexwale notes that the various elements of this offensive reveal a chillingly coherent campaign to cripple SA’s moral authority and destabilise its domestic politics. ‘The first missile landed on the tarmac of OR Tambo International Airport on Thursday. It was a charter flight carrying 153 stranded, confused and legally ambiguous Palestinians. For 12 hours, they were hostages in a geopolitical stand-off SA did not choose but was forced to resolve. The situation created an impossible dilemma for the authorities. By turning the passengers away, SA would have been seen as betraying its stated principles. However, by admitting them, it would have created the impression it was validating a process many regard as designed to facilitate the permanent displacement of Palestinians – and this would surely have inflamed public opinion.’ Sexwale says the second missile was launched by President Donald Trump, deploying the toxic and debunked narrative of ‘white genocide’ pushed by members of fringe Afrikaner lobby groups. The announcement of a boycott of the G20 summit ‘was not a spontaneous diplomatic disagreement, but rather the culmination of a calculated influence operation’.
‘Therefore, SA must mount a response as strategic and unflinching as the attack itself. The investigation into these flights must be public and forensic, and it must trace the money and the co-ordination to their sources. However, if the government’s assessment is wrong, a full and honest explanation must be given to the SA public. We must be told how, under a strict and total blockade, these individuals managed to secure a passage out of Gaza when millions of others cannot. President Ramaphosa must directly and publicly identify this co-ordinated siege. It is incumbent on him to address the nation and the world to expose the unholy alliance between a foreign state, a superpower’s political leadership and domestic lobby groups actively working against the national interest,’ Sexwale notes in the Sunday Times.
A Mail & Guardian editorial notes that Trump has used SA as a punchbag, defying all logic and sticking to his absurd claims of white genocide. ‘The G20 Summit could have offered him an opportunity to come to SA and see for himself that the narrative of whites being slaughtered and kicked off their land is just pure fiction. For Trump to now go further and demand that SA be axed from the G20 based on this falsehood is not only outrageous, but also idiotic. It is clear that beyond the summit, Trump’s disdain for SA will continue unless Pretoria draws a line in the sand.’