Back Print this page
Legalbrief   |   your legal news hub Monday 23 November 2026

Impeachment evidence leader challenge rejected

South Africa's Western Cape High Court has rejected an application challenging a decision by Parliament’s Section 89 Committee to withdraw the nomination of Advocate Thandazani Griffiths Madonsela as chief evidence leader in the impeachment inquiry involving President Cyril Ramaphosa. The court delivered the ruling on Friday, reports The Citizen. The case was pursued by opposition party, the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) and the African Legal Professionals Association (Alpa), with proceedings taking place over two days, on 13 and 14 October. The dispute arose after Ramaphosa objected to Madonsela’s nomination in a letter and questioned Madonsela’s previous involvement in the matter, including his provision of legal advice to the Ramapahosa's party, the ANC, on the impeachment issue. He also referred to Madonsela’s removal from the Judicial Service Commission in 2022, suggesting that the circumstances surrounding the matter could give rise to a potential conflict of interest. Following Ramaphosa’s objection, the committee withdrew its recommendation and reopened the nomination process. The parliamentary structure also put the selection of a replacement evidence leader on hold pending the outcome of the court proceedings.

Judge Chantel Fortuin indicated that two judgments were produced after the court ‘carefully considered the substantial arguments advanced by all the parties in this matter’. She revealed that the majority opted to throw out the applications by EFF and Alpa. ‘The second judgment, which dissents from the majority, concludes that both applications be granted for the reasons set out in that judgment. The dissenting judgment concludes that it would have reviewed and set aside the committee’s decision to rescind the recommendation with costs,’ Fortuin explained. The judges also accepted the EFF applicant’s late submission of legal arguments and waived procedural requirements concerning the prescribed service requirements and filing deadlines, notes The Citizen. The court made no ruling on legal costs. Section 89 Committee chairperson Makashule Gana welcomed the outcome and confirmed that the committee will resume its activities.